
The pharmacy shelf has dozens of tubes, jars and roll-ons that promise to cool, heat or numb your aching knee. They are not all the same, and some work much better than others.
Rub-on pain relievers are popular after 50 for a good reason: they put the medicine where it hurts, with far less of it reaching the rest of the body than a pill. But the active ingredient makes all the difference. Here’s what each type does, which ones have the best evidence for joint pain, and how to use them safely.
- Best evidence for arthritis: diclofenac gel, an anti-inflammatory gel sold without a prescription in the US since 2020.
- Capsaicin (from chili peppers) can help, but it burns at first and takes about two weeks of regular use.
- Menthol and camphor cool or warm the skin and distract from pain for a short time. They don’t treat the joint.
- Safety: never use with a heating pad or tight bandage, never on broken skin. Rare serious burns have been reported.
- See a doctor for a hot, red, swollen joint, pain after a fall, or pain that keeps you up at night.
The 5 types of pain rubs
Diclofenac gel (an NSAID) Strong evidence
The same type of medicine as ibuprofen, in a gel. In February 2020 the FDA approved diclofenac sodium gel 1% for sale without a prescription, for arthritis pain in the hands, wrists, elbows, knees, ankles and feet. It works best on joints close to the skin, like knees and hands, and usually needs a few days of regular use. Less of it reaches the stomach than with pills, but people with kidney problems, heart failure or an aspirin allergy should ask a doctor first.
Capsaicin Some evidence
The hot part of chili peppers. At first it burns or stings; with regular use (three to four times a day), the nerve endings send fewer pain signals. Give it about two weeks. Wash your hands well afterward and keep it away from your eyes.
Menthol and camphor Short-term relief
These are “counterirritants”: they make the skin feel cold or warm, which distracts the brain from the pain for a while. They are fine for sore muscles and a quick break from joint pain, but they don’t calm inflammation or protect the joint.
Salicylates Limited evidence
Methyl salicylate (wintergreen) and trolamine salicylate are relatives of aspirin. Avoid them if you’re allergic to aspirin or take blood thinners, and don’t use large amounts.
Lidocaine Some evidence
A numbing medicine in creams and 4% patches. More useful for nerve-type pain than for arthritis deep inside the joint.
Side-by-side comparison
| Type | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Diclofenac gel | Knee and hand arthritis | Kidney or heart problems, aspirin allergy, other NSAIDs |
| Capsaicin | Knee arthritis, nerve pain | Burning at first; eyes |
| Menthol / camphor | Quick relief, sore muscles | Burns with heat or high strengths |
| Salicylates | Sore muscles | Aspirin allergy, blood thinners |
| Lidocaine | Nerve-type pain | Broken skin, too many patches |
How to use them safely

- Read the Drug Facts label and use only the amount and number of times a day it says.
- Only on clean, unbroken skin. Never on cuts, rashes or sunburn.
- Never cover with a heating pad, hot water bottle or tight bandage.
- Wash your hands after use and keep away from eyes.
- Stop and get medical care if you feel strong burning, see blisters or redness. In 2012 the FDA warned about rare but serious chemical burns, mostly from products with menthol, or menthol plus methyl salicylate, often at higher strengths.
- Don’t use two products with the same type of medicine at once, like diclofenac gel plus ibuprofen pills, without asking your doctor.
- a joint is suddenly hot, red and swollen, or you have a fever
- the pain started after a fall or injury
- pain wakes you at night, or you can’t put weight on the leg
- pain doesn’t improve after 7 days of using a rub
What else helps sore joints
Keep moving Strong evidence
Exercise is one of the best treatments for knee and hip arthritis: walking, cycling, water exercise and strength work for the thigh muscles. See stiff knees in the morning.
Lose a little weight Strong evidence
Every pound lost takes several pounds of pressure off the knees with each step.
Heat or cold Some evidence
Warmth for stiffness, a wrapped cold pack for a flare. Use them separately from rubs, never at the same time.
Physical therapy Strong evidence
A therapist can teach exercises that fit your joints and show you how to protect them during daily tasks.

The one our readers ask about
Many pain drops and roll-ons sold online use menthol and camphor, the same counterirritants found in pharmacy rubs. That can give short relief, but it’s not the same as an anti-inflammatory gel.
Questions readers ask
What is the best cream for arthritis pain?
Diclofenac gel 1%, an anti-inflammatory sold without a prescription in the US since 2020, has the best evidence for knee and hand arthritis. Capsaicin can also help with regular use.
Do menthol creams actually work?
Menthol cools the skin and distracts from pain for a short time. It can help with sore muscles and give a short break from joint pain, but it doesn’t reduce inflammation or treat arthritis.
Is diclofenac gel safe for older adults?
Less of it reaches the bloodstream than with pills, so it is often preferred after 50. People with kidney disease, heart failure, an aspirin allergy or who take other NSAIDs or blood thinners should ask a doctor first.
How long does capsaicin cream take to work?
It usually takes about two weeks of regular use, three to four times a day. It stings at first; that feeling fades with use.
Can pain relief creams cause burns?
Rarely, yes. The FDA has warned about serious chemical burns, mostly from menthol or menthol plus methyl salicylate products. Never use them with heat or tight bandages, and stop if you feel strong burning.
Can I use a pain cream and take ibuprofen?
Don’t combine diclofenac gel with NSAID pills like ibuprofen or naproxen without your doctor’s OK. Menthol or capsaicin rubs can usually be used with pills, but ask your pharmacist.
This article is general information, not medical advice. Some links lead to our independent reviews, which contain affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Talk to your doctor before starting any new supplement.